As globalization increases, EU economy needs more highly skilled workers. Following the example of the US, there is a proposal to issue a Blue Card to attract non-EU highly skilled workers.
Blue card recipients will enjoy special working and living conditions in EU member states
Critics say that this policy will damage the working conditions of EU workers, in terms of salary, and also will encourage a brain draining in the countries where these highly skilled workers come from.
What do you think about this proposal, is appropriate?
Another side-effect is increasing corruption practices that this policy will generate. I'm positive sure that low skilled workers will gain access to Blue Cards, thanks to corrupted EU and States Members officials. As a matter of fact that will generate a black market of buying and selling cards. Only with very strict control measures can this mess be prevented. But I-m not very confident.
Nowadays, Europe civilization is incrising by the presence of immigrants. These immigrants are people who search a job and a new live in our country. But, immigrants who don't want these, only want to impose themselves in our society. Because of that I that blue cards for attracting non-EU highly skilled workers are the best way for immigrants who want to incorporate in our society and who want to adapt in our economy.
I personally agree with gerardbp. Since a long time the United States has this measure working with the green cards. People cualified to work would be garanteed by a minium salary, a civil conditions, and further more addapt to that conurty they are moving to. In the actual world of globalization that we are living in is a good aspect to look at.
I think is great! I think people from around the world deserve to have a chance of a dream job in the "land of oportunities"! there are many good and great persons who ahve a job that could be practised in teh US and they are not allowed to go because they have no passport .. or green card... they are just more immigrants who wants to work there.. adn thats not true.. Th americans should be more open minded and open their country to other maginifcient people who have the perfect skills and that will fit there as a ring in a finger. I think the proposal of a blue card is a good idea..bt.. honestly...I will add more conditions
In that moment that the world is in crisis all the countries needs the best professional to grow together. For that reason I believe in blue cards. Globalization is good in that way. I don’t believe that blue card will damage the working conditions of EU workers. I think is totally appropiate.
I agree with Gerard! I would like to add that Blue cards provides the oportunity to know how the people from the other countries works. I'm sure that the racist people will criticate it, but they don't have to forget that we are in a globalization world
Well, First of all I would like to say, that I am agree that the non EU workers could, if they want to, come to the EU to work. And I am not, in any way, a racist. I think that make a Blue card is not a bad way to increase the knowledge level there. But I have to say, that is the best solution for the EU, but not for the other countries. In this way I think that the foreign countries need their highly skilled workers to develop those countries in an economic and social way. If we increase a brain draining of the undeveloped countries, that we are doing actually, we force these to remain in a condition of poverty of which they it will be very difficult to go out. I believe that our responsibility as ex-colonial countries is to help those countries that we pillage from their richness’s to develop alone but with all our help.
From my point of view, I think that the Blue card allow us to know how the other people of different countries works. Also, we must remember that we are living in a globalization world and probably people criticise this idea.
I think it is a good idea, because we all have the sam rights and if sometimes we want to work to another countries and we have the same facilities, why the can't have it here. Working togther we will do great things for the world and the humanity
I believe that this kind of propose was a way of stopping the wave of illegal immigration that the UE has, in this way they can control the hard-working and autoregular workforce, the contracts of work too that before were illegals. On the other hand I think that another propose about the blue card is finish with the economic stagnation and reach qualified necessary workers and there power in sectors as the health or the education that need this kind of help in order to sectors like this one continue forward. Blue Card is an opportunity more than anythng.
I think that the idea of having highly skilled workers is very good for any nation, but i don´t agree with the idea of making a diference between the emigrants qualificateds and the ones who not. I think that if you´re a professional and you want to work in here, or in any country you have to offer your degree and search work as everyone, if you have it you will have a work and then the possibility to stay in that country. But I think that if this idea goes on, we will promove discrimination!There are more ways...
First, feel good that a person having a well qualified studies come from the country it comes from, is accepted in Europe as an able-bodied person to work in their field. But I see unfair because studies have not any reason to treat someone better than another.
I think that the foreigners who come from outside Europe must have the opportunity to work under the same conditions and with the same wages as those who are one's own country. When a person is sufficiently prepared to exercise a profession, no matter where you do, the important thing is that their work makes a contribution to society in a fair and honest.
I think this is great because a lot of high-qualified people that has to go to another country to work, often work in not really good jobs only for being foreigner, and that would be a great opportunity for them and for us if we want to work abroad.
My point of view in that topic is that it's a great idea to stablish in the UE members states the blue card becuase like that all the poeple in the world could work in Europe and have great opportunities becuase like that we could make a better conditions and equally conditions in all the countries in the world becuase in lots of places ( always in countries that are in war) have lots of good professionals and people really high-qualificate that could not work in what they want. I think that with that blue card we could be helping lots of people that needs one opportunity. On the other hand it's true that maybe the blue card will harm european people but i think that we could find solution to make a better world.
This measures could increase the investigation and development of reciving countries and sure it will promote the professional exchange between European countries. But, what about undeveloped countries? We should wait and help the 3th world. Who really needs highly skilled doctor? Development countries don't want to destine 0,7% of gdp and now we try to atractt peolple who can save his country.
I think that if the good workers of your nonEU country go to EU countries, you only have bad skilled workers for your nation and it will obviously affect to your economy and other issues. However it's a good idea for the EU countries because we'll get the high skilled workers to our jobs and that will increase our life quality.
Sincerely I don't have a clear opinion about that issue. Probably I need more information about it to be sure of what I think
I'm agree with the rest of the people who answer this blog.
This card allow the best people on his jobs changing their country and meeting new ways to work. Also, this think made to this people increase their knowing about their jobs, and meeting new people.
If I were a good foreigner professional I would like to have the chance to come to Europe to develop a job. To chare knowledge and experience is not bad. The only bad point it to not forget our professional that must have the same opportunities to work here. And not to use work as a way to control immigration.
Blue cards for attracting highly skilled workers is a system which the United States of America has been using for a long time. Europe should do the same as the USA or don't let our highly skilled workers go. If Europe adapts to this, it will be able to have more skilled workers.
The use of Blue- cards seem a useful way of attracting non EU skilled workers to the european community. Moreover, I believe that it would result as an opportunity of growth for the european society. In addition, if countries of origin of these workers are worried about brain draining, its their duty to promote and give their workers attractive opportunities. However, if these employees dont find interesting propositions in their home countries, I think they have the right to come to the EU.
Obviously the Blue Card will damage the working conditions of EU workers and our salary also. This Card is not and advantage for UE members because europeans will not be able to have tha same opportunities that no-europeans who acquires Card.
In addition, if we have few opportunities, it is not logical that another people (not the members of the UE) have any more opportunities that hard-working Europeans.
I think all the countries of the European Union have their jobs and their salary, and the non-UE members too. This Card will involve a lot of changes in all the system. I agree with Marta when she says that this card is not and advantatge.
I disagree with the idea, I think the system of the blue card is a disadvantage and discrimination towards others. I think it is unnecessary and that there are more important and urgent to spend the money and to show concern.
I can’t to give a clear opinion because I don’t have a lot of information about this subject. I only can say that I agree more or less with what Martí has said since partly the qualified workers who come to the countries of the European Union it provokes a growth in the quality of life.
I think that first of all, it should be better to promote this job in europe. If there are missing people in some field, first of all, they could promote that kind of job here and after ask for skilled people outside.
I think the measure is appropriate because it favors the lives of those foreigners who want to work anywhere in Europe and are well qualified to do so. The Blue Card will allow them to achieve a good salary and live their lives as normal as people of the country. Besides, her situation must be differentiated from other immigrants, those without any qualifications who move to Europe illegally, harming the safety and welfare of citizens.
I'm agree with that Romina has said. People who came to Europe to work and have qualifications they have to work because they need an oportunity that maybe don't have in their countries and moreover Europe will grown the quality of life.
I agree with Romina and Nina because all people in the world should have the same opportunity than other people with good position to work and earn some salary. These Blue Card is a good measure to people who are looking for job in Europe. Moreover, european citizens that don't want to work in some jobs, Blue Card allow immigrants to come to Europe and find differents jobs, without serious problems with authorites.
I don't think the blue card is such a great idea. In the first place, highly skilled workers are already attracted here by the companies that want them, offering them great salaries and facilities to live in Europe. The blue card would maybe attract some more, but in the end there would be less European highly skilled workers and I don't think we want to be dependant on other countries. In addition, as it is said at the begining of this discussion, there would be corruption and misuse of the cards, which would lead to a great discontent of European citizens.
I strongly believe that The Blue Card is a interesting and apropiate measure, that will allow those foreigners who are qualified to work in Europe, the possibility of a good salary and a better life quality. Besides, I consider relevant the fact that those foreigners must have the opportunity to work under the same conditions as the europeans, because they are sufficiently qualified.
However I agree with graccus in the fact that if we want this situation under control, and we don't want a black market of buying and selling cards, we need stric mesures to prevent this situation.
My point of view towards this topic is that the use of a Blue-card to attract non-EU highly skilled workers is a great idea. I believe that this proposal will give an oportunity to the non EU skilled workers to come to Europe. Moreover, I think that it’s a way to permit to the foreign employees who can’t find work in their countries, to come here and work. It’s true that this blue card will be negative for European people, but everyone is entitled to an opportunity.
If it is true can be abble. But I think that is very difficult to control that. In less than one month, everybody can make all the want and the new sistem had to be retirated. I propose to make it during some days in one city to comprovate if it is really comfortable.
From my point of view, I think that is reasonable because we will have many opportunities and biodiversity. However, it's so difficult control all. But on the other hand, I think they are discriminating against people with no college degree
I think know matter where are you from, you have the right to work everywhere. If you have the good conditions and your profile matches with the job there have to be no boundaries. That would work if no one used blue-cards as a way of creating his or her own business. There has to be a deep control to get to know that everything is under control.
Nowadays, the world is in crisis and all the countries needs the best professional to grow together. For that reason I believe in blue cards. The only bad point it to not forget our professional that must have the same opportunities to work in the country
I think, as MireiaGC4 does, that this iniciative is a good idea for immigrant people who can't work in their contries because of its economics or political situation. It's important for this people their immigration, because it's the only way they have to grow professionaly. It's important this card because it diferences this people with the other immigrants.
I don't think that blue cards are a good idea because they represent a lot of problems, for the EU countries and specially for the countries of origin of these non-EU highly skilled workers. First of all, these Blue Cards will encourage people from other countries to come to the EU to have a job, because they will be much better paid. And it is obvious that with the situation of crisis that we have these days, we don't need foreign people to fill vacancies. We need more jobs for the native people, because the unemployment is increasing. Moreover, it will cause important problems in their countries of origin, because they will loose the higlhy skilled workers. What are they going to do without these skilled workers?
First of all, I might say that blue cards may bring benefits to EU countries. It would guarantee equality between people, and we don't have to forget that we're living with globalisation. On the other hand, European countries are not living their best economical situation, and with the crisis a great deal of population has lost their former employment. Some might think that native people should have, at first, more opportunities to fill in the employment vacancies. And, this statement is also reasonable from my point of view. Nevertheless, like every issue, it has its advantages and disadvantages. If the Blue Cards system is finally approved, immigrants would also have more ways to find work and grow professionally. I think that the results won't b clear until the day comes.
In principal I 'm for the three movment people around the world. The EU Blue card iniciative is a way to manage tgis influx of people in some way you can look at it as the EU buying talent in other countries. I belive that by having more talented people in the Eu it will make all people better off.While it is true that we can expect down word pressure on salarys on the long round the productivity increase will benefit the socity at large.
The contruies of imigrants are olso better off. Firstly, because of the mony imigrants send back to their families and secontly because they tend to return to their conutries were conditions in prove and apply what they have learn back in their home countries. We have seen that in Spain with US educated and trained professional when they came back when Spain became a democratic country. A more reason example, is the high tech industry revolutin in India wich was possible by the return of highey skilled sovetware engineers traind aganin in the US.
I think that there are some countries in Europe that need people prepared for an specific work. In adition, this could be a good way to improve the crisis that is passing the entire world. If there is prepared people that isn't working in another country, why we can't accept them?